My wife, to her credit, hasn't played the typical cheater's handbook game. There's been no gaslighting, she's been honest in her answers to her questions, and has taken responsibility for her actions.
I wouldn't bet your house on that.
To put a quick timeline together....Affair end of 2016-most of 2017 (call it a year). More emotional than physical, but there was physical.
Maybe, but it was probably more physical than you realize. Guys don't have affairs with married women to exchange love-notes; they do it to fuck them with no strings attached.
My plan is to not jump to any decisions, go to couples and single counseling and see where I end up.
Skip the couples counseling unless you want to be made into a contributor to the affair, or an ogre for not treating her with proper sensitivity since you found out she was doing some other guy during your health crisis.
My biggest difficulty moving forward is that I don't know if I can forgive her. This isn't just about her affair. It's looking at the holes and weaknesses in how she treated me, before, during and even since her affair....and how it compares to how she treated her affair partner.
I put a large portion of my "love equation" in loyalty. My wife tends to be selfish, abrupt in how she speaks at times (it's a personality thing, not an ill-intent thing), etc. etc., in other words there are parts of who she is and how she treated me that I wouldn't normally accept from other people, but because I always saw her as loyal....I could forgive those other parts (this isn't an issue of being a doormat either, I'd set her straight if she went too far and she'd apologize etc.). Finding out she cheated though has created a paradigm shift if how I'm seeing our relationship and I don't know if I can forgive her and find my love for her again.
This all makes perfect sense. One thing you can say for sure is that she is not a loyal person. Think long and hard as to what she considers you as, and if you want to go back to that.
But I can't see how I can forgive her and let go of the years of poor treatment. I have an INCREDIBLE amount of resentment right now.
The question is really, can you live with someone who has betrayed you in such an ugly manner? If you can, then maybe you can attempt to reconcile. Of course, you have to understand who you are reconciling with. I am not a big believer in people changing. I am also not someone who care very much about people changing after they have taken a shit on me.
But that is just my point of view.
***
It's incredibly tough. I am just some guy on the internet, so I am ready to divorce your wife yesterday. But with family, the fact that this is all new to you - she has been out of love with you FOR YEARS, and your loving-heart has just been smashed!
But, my man, your wife sounds like one cold ****. Ask yourself if that is the kind of person you want to keep in your life, for the rest of your life. Will it eat at you for the rest of your life?
Most cheaters don't give a shit. They just want to "get out of trouble" after they had their fun and go back to the way things were before. They don't understand that ship sailed.
You have some thinking to do. But here is the thing. Don't be too nice to her. In fact, don't be nice. Put her to the side and let her know she has ended the marriage and your life decisions are going to be made by you. Show strength. Try not to whine or cry to her. She will view your vulnerability as weakness, the same way she took advantage of your time of illness. Easier said than done!
Also, assume everything she tells you is a lie, minimized, omitted, or distorted. You should start investigation and surveillance on her life that she has been leading in secret.
Look through all her old phones, texts, emails, whatever you can find. Get a recorder and leave it recording where she talks the most. Give her the business then leave. See who she calls, who she talks to, and what she says. You will only get the truth when you are not around.
Good luck to you.