Cookies are required for login or registration. Please read and agree to our cookie policy to continue.

Newest Member: Plantlady

The Book Club :
The Girl on the Train

Topic is Sleeping.
default

 Ascendant (original poster member #38303) posted at 1:39 AM on Monday, February 9th, 2015

http://www.amazon.com/The-Girl-Train-A-Novel/dp/1594633665

It's really, really good, in my opinion. It's like Gone Girl, but with a (somewhat) sympathetic protagonist.

Warning: Ultra-triggery. I mean it. Infidelity is practically oozing out of every page....not in a way that glorifies it, but it is there.

posts: 5193   ·   registered: Jan. 30th, 2013   ·   location: North of Chicago, Illinois
id 7110456
default

Futurefear ( member #43176) posted at 4:42 AM on Monday, February 9th, 2015

Awesome! I've been looking for a new book. I did enjoy Gone Girl however wasnt expecting the twists and turns.

me- BW him-cheater (2 during our marriage, still with dirty whore)
together 10 yrs, married 7.5
kids- 2 DD and 1 DS
DD#1-Jan 2014,#2-2/2014, #3-3/2014
Filed 4/2014, divorce final 5/2015

posts: 700   ·   registered: Apr. 20th, 2014   ·   location: Iowa
id 7110657
default

Jrazz ( member #31349) posted at 5:15 AM on Tuesday, February 10th, 2015

Completely non-rhetorical question - how are you able to enjoy the book if it's "ultra triggery?"

I completely trust your judgement in what makes a book good, but I couldn't bring myself to pick up Gone Girl based on what I'd heard about the premise.

Can you expand on what made the book worth reading?

"Don't give up, the beginning is always the hardest." - Deeply Scared's mom

posts: 29076   ·   registered: Feb. 28th, 2011   ·   location: California
id 7112122
default

Skye ( member #325) posted at 12:54 PM on Tuesday, February 10th, 2015

I have it on my TBR list. Sure hope it is better than "Gone Girl." Infidelity isn't a trigger for me but glad you made that warning for others. Happy couples are my trigger.

posts: 5662   ·   registered: Jul. 21st, 2002
id 7112287
default

 Ascendant (original poster member #38303) posted at 3:10 PM on Tuesday, February 10th, 2015

Ok, by 'good', I mean exciting. Kept my attention, made me want to eat the book alive in one sitting.

As per the infidelity aspect, I don't want to be spoilery, but the main character's husband had an affair, married the AP, and then got her pregnant, and seemingly has a perfect little life and family. The BW has become a stumbling drunk in the wake of all this, while the OW absolutely fucking revels in the idea of both being an OW (first), and then replacing the BW (second). She goes at length about how disgusting the xBW is and how much better than her she is and how powerful the events make her feel...anything more would ruin it.

That's what I mean by triggery.

posts: 5193   ·   registered: Jan. 30th, 2013   ·   location: North of Chicago, Illinois
id 7112415
default

asurvivor ( member #32368) posted at 5:44 PM on Tuesday, February 10th, 2015

I just finished this book last night. Without going into the detail, my review is not as glowing as yours (has nothing to do with the infidelity theme) but it's OK, kept my attention and was worth the read. I will say that I'm usually well over any infidelity triggery shit but I have to admit, on occasion this book did piss me off.

I've wiped the shit off. It can be wiped off you know.


posts: 642   ·   registered: Jun. 3rd, 2011
id 7112613
default

Skye ( member #325) posted at 1:57 PM on Wednesday, February 11th, 2015

asurvivor, curioushow did you like "Gone Girl?" And how would you coompare the two?

posts: 5662   ·   registered: Jul. 21st, 2002
id 7113484
default

pizzalover ( member #38336) posted at 7:35 PM on Friday, February 13th, 2015

I just finished it today. I really liked it. It kept me guessing throughout. I recommend it.

Trying to rebuild each day

Me - WW 41
Him - BH 41 (mpb1974)
2 Furrbabies - sweet cats

Met - 8/13/99
Started dating - 9/11/99
Moved in together - 3/03
Engaged - 6/5/09
Married - 8/21/10
D-Day - 1/24/13
Affair started 5/09

posts: 779   ·   registered: Feb. 3rd, 2013   ·   location: Pennsylvania
id 7116795
default

ILINIA ( member #39836) posted at 2:09 AM on Friday, April 10th, 2015

I was just SI-surfing and saw this thread. I literally just finished last night.

I did not know about the A theme before I read it, but these days it seems every book, movie, and tv show have some sort of reference. I was nice that it wasn't glorified, but more shown as how messed-up it all is.

Since it was after Gone Girl, I don't think I was as shocked when it took its turn. Also, I was getting a bit impatient with the story and frustrated with the main character that I almost cracked open a bottle of wine.

[This message edited by ILINIA at 8:10 PM, April 9th (Thursday)]

posts: 930   ·   registered: Jul. 15th, 2013
id 7181505
default

miadianna ( member #10516) posted at 8:33 PM on Tuesday, April 14th, 2015

I just finished this book and loved it! My daughter got it from the library and read it. It had 829 holds on it. It's a mystery thriller, moves fast and and one of those books you can't stop reading once you start. She warned me of the triggery aspect of it, but it didn't affect me the same way as it might others. Because of the way the book unfolds, it's not glorified as someone else mentioned.

I thought it was better than Gone Girl. I would definitely recommend it.

Me: BS 60Son: 34years oldDaughter: 32 years old Divorced 4/10/08XH passed away 6/24/16

posts: 7542   ·   registered: Apr. 26th, 2006
id 7187095
default

Cally60 ( member #23437) posted at 11:17 AM on Wednesday, April 15th, 2015

I thought it was better than Gone Girl. I would definitely recommend it.

And for me it was the opposite! I thought that Gone Girl was the better book, but I really enjoyed The Girl on the Train, too.

A less recent book that I couldn't put down (but sometimes had to read from behind the sofa) was Before I Go to Sleep by S. J. Watson. I highly recommend it.

[This message edited by Cally60 at 5:22 AM, April 15th (Wednesday)]

posts: 2478   ·   registered: Mar. 30th, 2009   ·   location: California
id 7187766
default

miadianna ( member #10516) posted at 10:01 PM on Wednesday, April 15th, 2015

Thanks for the recommendation, Cally. I will check that one out. I loved Gone Girl but was sort of expecting more at the end, but it was great too.

Me: BS 60Son: 34years oldDaughter: 32 years old Divorced 4/10/08XH passed away 6/24/16

posts: 7542   ·   registered: Apr. 26th, 2006
id 7188465
default

wildbananas ( member #10552) posted at 4:45 PM on Thursday, April 16th, 2015

I read this not very long ago and liked it but I have to say I liked "Gone Girl" much more.

Travel light, live light, spread the light, be the light. ~ Yogi Bhajan

posts: 16592   ·   registered: May. 1st, 2006   ·   location: Somewhere
id 7189283
default

rachelc ( member #30314) posted at 2:16 PM on Monday, April 27th, 2015

so far so good...

posts: 7613   ·   registered: Dec. 6th, 2010   ·   location: Midwest
id 7201592
default

downintx ( member #46244) posted at 11:54 PM on Tuesday, May 12th, 2015

I'm six months out from catching my wife from having an emotional affair, which at the same time led me to finding out that she had a sexual affair a couple years ago. I found her reading this book till all hours of the morning - said she was reading it because she drank coffee late and could not sleep. She also said a friend recommended the book, and she did not know it was about an affair. I find it crazy how she made an effort to go and buy this specific book, when she belongs a book club, and did not take this book on her book club night to share with the others. I would appreciate some input and thoughts on what others think of my wife reading a book like girl on a train just six months out from DD...

[This message edited by downintx at 6:03 PM, May 12th (Tuesday)]

You Can't Change the Wind but You Can Adjust the Sails.

If YOU don't change, things will stay the same.

posts: 149   ·   registered: Jan. 7th, 2015
id 7218331
default

tushnurse ( member #21101) posted at 8:50 PM on Wednesday, May 27th, 2015

I enjoyed it. I'm far out though, I could see it being triggery, depending on your situation.

I did enjoy it, and read it in a few days.

Me: FBSHim: FWSKids: 23 & 27 Married for 32 years now, was 16 at the time.D-Day Sept 26 2008R'd in about 2 years. Old Vet now.

posts: 20298   ·   registered: Oct. 1st, 2008   ·   location: St. Louis
id 7233766
default

trophywife411 ( member #47784) posted at 3:06 AM on Thursday, June 4th, 2015

The audio version was great too. The three characters are all in different voices and one sounds like my British best friend, the other like Keira Knightly, and I couldn't place the third (AP), so I had to think of some made up horrible person for that one.

I listened to it right before dday, so wasn't trigger for me yet...probably would be at only three months out though...

Me-BW 40
fWH 45
together 18 years, married 16
Dday March 2015, Final TT 6/17/15
Reconciling

posts: 858   ·   registered: May. 6th, 2015
id 7241899
default

downintx ( member #46244) posted at 3:09 AM on Thursday, June 4th, 2015

my ow bought this book just a few months from DDay - do you think reading about an affair gets them all excited, or is it more of a validation thing - that if they can do it, it was okay for me to do it...

You Can't Change the Wind but You Can Adjust the Sails.

If YOU don't change, things will stay the same.

posts: 149   ·   registered: Jan. 7th, 2015
id 7241903
default

OnceInALifetime ( member #26023) posted at 5:31 AM on Thursday, June 4th, 2015

Finished the book about a week ago and am looking for something else to read. I didn't find any of the characters in this book likable, but it held my interest.

@downintx, of course we can't know why your wife started reading this book. I think it paints a very ugly picture around cheating, so if she started reading it to feel better about what she had done, it would have likely backfired. Maybe she read it for insight into her own warped thinking that led to her cheating? Did you ask her what she thought of it?

[This message edited by OnceInALifetime at 11:31 PM, June 3rd, 2015 (Wednesday)]

BH, now divorced

posts: 3529   ·   registered: Oct. 29th, 2009   ·   location: New England
id 7242011
default

circe ( member #6687) posted at 4:46 PM on Thursday, June 4th, 2015

The audio version was great too. The three characters are all in different voices and one sounds like my British best friend, the other like Keira Knightly,

Omg I'm listening to this right now and I know right? the one voice is a dead ringer for Keira Knightly and also Cersei Lannister (game of thrones) - they sound very much alike to me!

The "OW" voice is dull and dim sounding, which made me quite happy!

Everything I ever let go of has claw marks on it -- Infinite Jest

posts: 3459   ·   registered: Mar. 19th, 2005
id 7242478
Topic is Sleeping.
Cookies on SurvivingInfidelity.com®

SurvivingInfidelity.com® uses cookies to enhance your visit to our website. This is a requirement for participants to login, post and use other features. Visitors may opt out, but the website will be less functional for you.

v.1.001.20241101b 2002-2024 SurvivingInfidelity.com® All Rights Reserved. • Privacy Policy